Comparing Fly Catching Methods
July 29, 2009
Over the last couple of summers we have had our fair share of insects. It became so bad at one stage, I went online to see if I could find anyone who had a good solution. That’s when I came across this solution on YouTube. I did a bit of a comparison to see if really could outperform traditional fly paper.

The YouTube solution is basically to place a dish of one part water, one part light coloured vinegar and a dash of detergent out to catch flies. I’m unclear on the science behind it, though I read somewhere that it is something to do with breaking the surface tension of the liquid. Another site suggested that the flies are attracted by the scent of the vinegar. In my case, I used tap water, some white wine vinegar (posh I know, but all we had) and some generic washing up liquid.

For fly paper I have some “fly stickers”, about the same surface area as the dishes, which are cleverly designed to look like a flower.

I put one sticker beside a vinegar dish outside and did the same at the same spot inside. Catching flies outside is a bit futile but I thought it would make for a good comparison. After two weeks here are the results (for insects greater in length than about 1 mm):

As you can see, inside (where the real problem is ) there is no difference between the two methods, with the sticker performing marginally better.
What was surprising to me was that in the dish outside with only 12 flies, there were also hundreds (literally) of insects about 1mm or smaller. These were largely absent from the inside dish. There was also a much more diverse selection of insects in the outside dish: (outside top, inside bottom)


I guess this is a tribute to the insect biodiversity out on the balcony! I was once under the impression that container gardening leaves you less likely to experience insects but this summer we have noticed bees, wasps, flea beetles, earwigs, centipedes, caterpillars, mites and many types of fly on the balcony to name a few.
As regards the experiment, I don’t think that there is any real difference between the two methods, but they both seem to do a reasonable job. I would say whichever is most convenient or cheapest is probably the best. I would also like to add that our fly problem is not as bad as it was last year so it might be worth investigating again when we have a really bad infestation. Let’s hope it doesn’t come to that.
There are three other common methods I didn’t consider that are worth a mention:
Honey: A lot of people on the Internet use honey to catch flies. I guess this would have a similar effect to the sticker, although perhaps the flies would be attracted by the sugary substance.
Venus Fly Trap: While entertaining, fly traps don’t have a very high insect turnover. I had one for a number of years, which is now sadly in carnivorous plant heaven, and even in its heyday it would struggle to consume more than about one insect a month.
A Dish of Water: This probably won’t catch any insects, but I just wanted to preempt anyone who came on and commented that I should have used a proper control!

























